You cut me so deep but you couldn't see the marks But you know that doesn't mean you didn't tear my soul apart And left me crying in the dark Like an icepick in my heart I couldn't give you what you want You said you need more And almost every night you went slipping out the door You left me crying in the dark Like an icepick through my heart I know it's over now, and my heart can start to heal Yes the hurt will never go away, it's a pain I'll always feel No I'll never lose the scar from your icepick to my heart