Fingers trace your skin All your cliffs and peaks And your hair it flows like waterfalls Wanna give some color back to your cheeks Fingers intertwine As you tell me you can't take it any more Let our hearts and souls combine While hell is knocking at our door Mermaid, sing to me He don't love you like I do He won't take your pain away You know it's true I wanna see you smile, wanna see you cry Oh, you're such a fool We should get some bruises falling in love 'Cause I love it when you're blue Yeah, it's making me mad Knowing I can treat you better than he could And your tears they flow like waterfalls And I don't think they should Yeah, it's okay to smile Even if inside it's tearing you apart No he'll never love you in the way that I do Why'd you go and give someone like that your heart? Mermaid, sing to me He don't love you like I do He won't take your pain away You know it's true I wanna see you smile, wanna see you cry Oh, you're such a fool We should get some bruises falling in love 'Cause I love it when you're blue (Underneath our skin our blood runs blue) Our blood runs blue (No he'll never love you like I do) I still love you And what am I to say? What was I supposed to say? What am I to say? Just tell me what to say What am I supposed to say? What am I to say? We threw it all away And we're still blue