I see you posting online, hoping I’ll take the bait Hoping that I’ll blow up like last time, so you can save face ‘Cause I’m the bad guy Or did you forget that, or did you forget that I won’t let you be a liar Darling you’re a black cat, nothing but a black cat Another witch in the fire So cast your spells and mix your potions I ain’t gonna be the one to spoil your fun baby We’re just going through the motions But tell me have you checked the score lately Girl don’t tempt me with a good time You know the dark doesn’t scare me ‘Cause every day is Halloween You were the best disguise I’d ever seen Don’t you undress me with a smooth lie You know damn well that you’re poison Salem, Salem Go back where you came from I hear your new man hates me, well isn’t that cute Did you tell him I’m crazy (crazy) I guess you’re right, I dated you ‘Cause I’m the big bad singer with the bad temper I’m the cold heartbreaker girl don’t you remember You’ve made me out to be your deepest, darkest fantasy ‘Cause every couples’ got their demons It just so happens you’re the queen of every one of them I know you’ll say you’ve got your reasons Well so do I and I wrote a whole song of them Girl don’t tempt me with a good time You know the dark doesn’t scare me ‘Cause every day is Halloween You were the best disguise I’d ever seen Don’t you undress me with a smooth lie You know damn well that you’re poison Salem, Salem Go back where you came from Just like a zombie you rise from the dead Get dressed up, grab your gun, there’s a price on my head And is there any other way you really thought this would end At the end of the day, that mirror is your only friend Turn the lights out for the last time Put your body on my body ’till nostalgia doesn’t feel right Until nostalgia doesn’t feel Put your body on my body ’till nostalgia doesn’t feel right Girl don’t tempt me with a good time You know the dark doesn’t scare me ‘Cause every day is Halloween You were the best disguise I’d ever seen Don’t you undress me with a smooth lie You know damn well that you’re poison Salem, Salem Go back where you came from Girl don’t tempt me with a good time You know the dark doesn’t scare me ‘Cause every day is Halloween You were the best disguise I’d ever seen Don’t you undress me with a smooth lie You know damn well that you’re poison Salem, Salem Go back where you came from