[Verse 1] Four days and a call that didn't come through Cold air and a love that never grew [Chorus] So why'd you keep me around? Why'd you keep me around? Just stumbling in the dark, dear Just stumbling in the dark [Verse 2] Four months and a man walks up to you Forget every lie, just tell the truth [Chorus] Why'd you keep him around? Why'd you keep him around? Just stumbling in the dark, dear Just stumbling in the dark [Verse 3] Four years and a new man falls for you So why fight it when you think you might love him too? Old habits die hard or they never do Keep lying 'till they all catch up to you [Chorus] But you should keep him around You should keep him around Don't throw him in the dark, dear Don't throw him in the dark [Outro] Don't throw him in the dark, dear Don't throw him in the dark