First star I see tonight. When we broke up - that would be pain said you'd never see me again thought you still cared - Every things right make this wish come true tonight. First star I see tonight Tell her I love her, tell her I care tell her true love through life I would share shine down on love and you shine on me tell her about our life's misery First star I see tonight. Why must it always be this way your never mine through the day but at night memories return see her back - still her love I still yearn First star I see tonight. Tonight - Tonight - Tonight.