It started out and everything was fine and swell I was crushin' and she could tell She's kinda punk but she likes The Kinks and Queen Gossip girl, and fashion magazines (Did you ask her out?) I did last week Went to a movie She kissed my cheek (Did you see her again?) I did last night Went to a party She got quite a sight I kissed her sister Couldn't resist her charms Now I'm in trouble I'm seein' double, oh no How the hell was I supposed to know? She's got a twin oh say it isn't so Should have studied her freckles and her quirks Now I'm a loser look like a jerk (So she walked in on you?) She saw me in the kitchen Then she started b**hin' (Understandably so) What was I to do? Suddenly there were two I kissed her sister Couldn't resist her charms Now I'm in trouble I'm seein' double, oh no I kissed her sister Couldn't resist her charms Now I'm in trouble I'm seein' double, oh no Honest mistake (x8) Why didn't she tell me? If she don't forgive me what will I do? I just gotta tell her I only kissed her 'cause I thought she was you Let's go listen to Buzzco*ks Rock out to Tupac Forget all this small talk Walk on the beach s** down a milkshake During an earthquake Spare me the heartbreak It's an honest mistake (So she walked in on you?) She saw me in the kitchen Then she started b**hin' (Understandably so) What was I to do? Suddenly there were two I kissed her sister Couldn't resist her charms Now I'm in trouble I'm seein' double, oh no I kissed her sister Couldn't resist her charms Now I'm in trouble I'm seein' double, oh no