She was standin' by the bar
At the club we were playin'
Half an hour before the show
I couldn't stop starin'
So finally I decided to say hello
She'd never seen the band, but she was a fan
She'd heard a couple o' songs online
We sat there talking 'til the club filled up
And it was showtime
I said, "I didn't catch your name"
She said, "Amy"
I said, "Will I see you after the show?"
She said, "Maybe"
And all night I tried
To look out at that crowd and find her
But those lights were so damn bright
Up there
So I said
"We've got time for one more song
You all know it so sing along
Gonna sing it out to a girl
I hope she's still here"
And I sang
"Amie, what you wanna do?
I think that I could stay with you
For a while, maybe longer if I do"
Yeah, yeah
With a girl like her
The best you can hope to do is date her off and on
You think it's going great
You turn around one day and she'll be gone
And she's beautiful and sweet
And complicated
She'll break my heart
And then she'll show up where I'm playing
So all night I tried
To look out at that crowd and find her
But those lights were so damn bright
Up there
So I said
"We've got time for one more song
You all know it so sing along
Gonna sing it out to a girl, I hope she's still"
And I sing
"Amie, what you wanna do?
I think that I could stay with you
Oh, for a while, maybe longer if I do"
Yeah, yeah
Oh, I keep falling in and out of love with you
Falling in and out of love with you
I don't know what I'm gonna do
'Cause I keep falling in and out of love
With you
Yeah, yeah