You smiled hello as we battled the snow Two strangers in New York I started a line, my words frozen in time as we Turn left on Lafayette You promised me you would But you never could You say you will I'm waitin' still Woah You should've seen me back when we were young And seen me do all those things I'd done You might've loved me Back when we were young As you made your escape It all seemed too late I descended the stairs to the dark With a whiskey in hand And perhaps some divine plan You appeared just in time You promised me you would But you never could You say you will I'm waitin' still Woah You should've seen me back when we were young And seen me do all those things I'd done You might've loved me Back when we were young Woah You smiled hello as we battled the snow Two strangers in New York