It's a fragile situation It could fall apart at any time And none would be the wiser 'Cept you and I It seems that we stopped talking Like we're afraid to disagree And after we've been through Can we still be that naive CHORUS If my heart isn't in it Why can't you tell me so If my heart wasn't in it I'd have gone long ago If your heart isn't in it Why keep me hanging on Just tell me and I'll be gone From your life You treat me like a stranger As if I wasn't there Oh, baby, I waited for a miracle To make you show that you care CHORUS If your heart isn't in it Why can't... I can't go through the motions I have to know If your heart isn't in it Why can't you tell me so I can't go to the limit I have to know If your heart... Ooh, can't you tell me so I have to know If your heart isn't it Why keep me hanging on Just tell me and I'll be gone Don't keep me hanging on For dear life