Oh oh oh Sheila, you were the first girl I ever loved
Oh Sheila, I met you down at the wrestling club
Down at the wrestling club
Oh oh oh Sheila, you got two arms wrapped around my neck
Oh Sheila, you reach to me from another's bed
From another wa*ker
Oh Sheila, you were the first girl I ever loved
Oh Sheila, you were the first girl I loved
Oh oh oh Sheila, you were the first girl my heart desired
Oh Sheila, come back and set my heart on fire
Set my heart on fire
Oh Sheila