Whatever happened to Mary I never see her with you
You're not confessing but I'm guessing she found somebody new
Did she slip right through your fingers the way she slipped through mine
And made you just another broken heart she left behind
Whatever happened to Mary since you took her from me
I can't recapture all her rapture except in memory
She's still the girl I dream of my world that fell apart
The hope I carry is that Mary will happen back to my heart
Whatever happened to Mary I never see her with you...